1860-1900, Paolo Mantegazza and the dream of ‘making’ science popular
By Cristiano TurbilItaly, since the unification, became a country where cultural and political differences somehow learnt to cohabit. This was achieved, among other initiatives, by popularising science and medicine in order to educate the general public about matters of national interest. This popularisation was carried out by the combined effort of scientists, politicians and editors, and in different ways, these actors equally contributed to explaining to the first generation of Italians the meaning of living in a united nation. One of the leading figures that contributed to this change in the public reception of science in Italy was the neurologist, anthropologist and politician Paolo Mantegazza (1831–1910).
Roberto Ardigò and the father of criminology Cesare Lombroso, Mantegazza started advocating the teaching of positivism. In particular, influenced by the work of French anthropologist Paul Broca, Mantegazza recognised the importance of teaching science to the general public in order to create a better society.
This became a common theme in Mantegazza’s work and political activity. In 1865, Mantegazza was elected, for the municipality of Monza, as a member of the italian parliament. He served first in the parliament and then in the senate for over 20 years. For Mantegazza, politics was the only way to implement his medical ideas and vision of science on a national level. On 4 November 1880, Mantegazza gave a talk titled ‘La Scienza nell’Italia Nuova’ (Science in the New Italy) at the Istituto di Studi Superiori Pratici e di Perfezionamento (University of Firenze). In the talk, while celebrating the achievements of the young italian kingdom, Mantegazza clearly emphasised the need for the rise of national science in both its professional and popular forms, and without distinction between the two. The unification of the country started, for Mantegazza, a period of prosperity for the nation. However, this prosperity which was clearly reflected in the development of the italian economy, art and literature did not happen for italian science. This was because, he explained, italian politicians were unable to see the importance that science was acquiring in many other countries across Europe. italian science was lacking in foundation and scope. Therefore, Mantegazza insisted that scientific research should be largely supported by the italian government, especially via internal funding. This was because, he explained, the improvement of any scientific knowledge should be the highest aspiration of any civil society.
In 1881, Mantegazza advanced the idea to stop thinking about having a science of the right or of the left. Instead, he suggested creating a nationally founded science of the nation. In order to do that, he asked italian scientists to go out of their laboratories and museums to communicate and explain the message of science to everyone. On 1 January 1884, Mantegazza returned to this point in the first edition of the italian scientific periodical La Natura (the italian version of the far more famous English periodical Nature). In the article, he urged italian scientists to popularise their work in order to use science as a guide for society and to make it accessible to everyone.
In just over 30 years of constant work, Paolo Mantegazza contributed, like no other, to the establishment of popular science in Italy. His efforts to make science popular were conducted through various initiatives on both a professional and popular level. The study of Mantegazza’s life and work tells us part of the history of italian popular science but also, more specifically, shows how popularisation of science did not only contribute to the extension of scientific literacy but also to constructing a sense of national identity and cohesion in a country which was, for far too long, divided. Mantegazza’s call to reach out to the public, in particular, offers an insight into an early form of the public culture of science.
Read the full paper Paolo Mantegazza and the dream of ‘making’ science popular circa 1860–1900 by Cristiano Turbil
More articles about Historical Moments in Public Understanding of Science
Cristiano Turbil is currently teaching history of science and medicine in the History Department at King's College London. Cristiano's research interests include nineteenth and early twentieth-century European history of biological sciences and medicine and their influence on the political, philosophical and cultural discourse