By Elina Uutela.
![]() |
| Image source: stock photo, edited by Elina Uutela. |
As platforms account for an increasing share of media consumption, traditional experts are finding it more compelling to build their presence there. Doctors on Instagram are one example. We analyzed how doctors balance their professional presence on social media with its personal and promotional elements.
The public understanding of science relies on science being present and visible in society. As the media environment continues to change rapidly, driven by new technologies, platformization, and the attention economy, science and science-based knowledge also need new routes to engage audiences.
Experts have a strong foothold in journalism, where they are constantly used to bring factuality and deeper commentary to news stories, even though the relationship is not without tension. But what happens when traditional science-based experts—in our case, doctors—start engaging with the public on social media? The situation is new to both the experts building their presence and the audiences following them.
Our take on doctors on social media draws from two directions: existing research on the expansion of expertise, widely discussed in science and technology studies, and Thomas Gieryn's concept of boundary work.
Expansion of expertise in the contemporary media
The role of experts and expertise in society continues to evolve, and their definitions remain contested. The expansion of expertise refers to the social acceptance of epistemic authorities widening beyond traditional professions. Most notably, it has been analyzed by Harry Collins and Robert Evans. The expansion of expertise has many drivers and can be analyzed in several contexts, but in our case, the most relevant is the market-driven one: as individual citizens’ demand for expertise grows, traditional experts can’t meet it, which attracts new actors.
Traditionally, expertise has been associated with formal education, scientific knowledge, and professional organizations. Medical doctors are a classic example: licensed professionals with formal education and a code of norms who apply medical science in their work.
New media environments, however, offer a way to bypass traditional gatekeeping. Rather than seeking a place in existing knowledge-shaping structures, new actors seeking expert status use the changing media environment to reach audiences directly. Instead of formal education, these actors rely on self-learning and experience to gain understanding and become skilled media actors. Often, these actors are recognized by a more limited audience, such as paying customers or an online follower base. However, on social media, their reach can grow to be meaningful—and whoever steps into these environments competes with them for audience attention.
Boundary work on social media
When traditional experts like doctors take to social media platforms such as Instagram, they need to balance their professional role with the platform’s requirements. Doctors as public experts both enact and expand expertise through their social media activity, gradually changing what public expertise looks like.
We analyze this as boundary work in relation to publics, the self, and markets. We examine how doctors enact expertise—specifically, by expressing epistemic authority, foregrounding their professional role, and emphasizing their impartiality—and expand it by catering to public expectations, sharing personal exposure, and using promotional tactics.
First, regarding publics, doctors enacted expertise by expressing their own and their profession’s epistemic authority over laypeople and self-trained experts. On the other hand, they expanded expertise by noting public expectations and addressing their followers' worries and questions, aiming to connect with them. Thus, audiences had the power to set the agenda.
Second, in relation to the self, doctors balanced professional and personal self-disclosure. In a way, on social media, doctors balance being knowledgeable, like a doctor, with being approachable and popular, like an influencer. According to our results, doctors actively communicated their professional role through visual imagery and discussions of workplace and medical practices. They also expanded expertise by sharing personal information, emotions, and experiences of healthcare as a patient. Self-trained and alternative experts often use experience to increase credibility.
Third, boundary work in relation to markets meant balancing expert impartiality with the platform’s promotional nature. According to our results, doctors protected their professional impartiality by adhering to their professional norms. However, doctors adopted new earning models, such as commercial collaborations, books, and online courses, and thus expanded expertise.
Changing the public representation of expertise?
Our results suggest that doctors’ use of new media brings both problems and benefits. On one hand, when trustworthy sources adapt their communication to fit platform norms, their content can start to resemble lifestyle or misinformation content, making it harder for audiences to distinguish between them. However, doctors seem to be interesting on social media, in part, exactly because they are doctors and use it as a feature to stand out.
Even if the boundaries of trustworthy knowledge on Instagram are slightly blurry, shouldn’t effective, trustworthy communication happen on the platforms where people spend their time? If doctors didn’t use new platforms, someone else would fill that space. Much depends on how doctors choose to use the platform and on their motivations and goals. While in a small market like Finland influencer revenue is not necessarily as lucrative as simply focusing on doctors’ work, in larger markets there is greater monetary potential. We thus expect that the analysis of professionals’ boundary work will remain relevant in the coming years.
Read the full article: Experts’ boundary work on social media: Doctors on Instagram.

