Skip to main content

Social Media Disconnection at the Top of Research Universities

By Leena Ripatti-Torniainen and Karoliina Talvitie-Lamberg.

Image source: Pixnio.

When we began studying voluntary social media non-use, we started from a counterintuitive observation. Public discourse and academic organisations in Finland increasingly portrayed social media use as a necessity, almost a condition of existence in contemporary digital society. Individuals often had to actively resist the pressure to participate in social media platforms. For example, an unemployed job seeker may be told that their lack of social media presence signals non-existence in society and its job markets, similar to a death. In this cultural climate, it seemed important to investigate why some people did not experience this pressure. Why did they voluntarily choose to opt out of social media?

We chose academic senior leaders in Finland’s research universities as one of the groups under study. An initial screening conducted by our research assistant, MSocSc Roosa Kontiokari, indicated that more than one quarter of university leaders in Finland lacked active accounts on major social media platforms, a considerably higher proportion than we had expected. After sending personal email invitations to participate in research interviews, I received an immediate response that seemed to express both support for investigating the topic and a need to speak out. Our later findings provided an explanation for this reaction.

The results showed that the senior leaders’ social media disconnection is deeply connected to their self-concept and their personal and professional identities. Absence from social media is not incidental and not a decision lightly made. In contrast, it is a deliberate and well-considered choice. Our study also systematically revealed the socially and structurally maintained conditions in research universities that make social media disconnection an affordable act. 

First, the choice of not communicating through social media makes sense inside the scientific community because its communication culture differs substantially from that of social media. Second, the internal tensions of today’s research university are tangibly felt by the leaders who aim at leading carefully and respectfully and avoid exacerbating divisions on largely uncontrollable social media platforms. Third, senior leaders are participants in the insider networks of society, which provides them with access to information and influence regardless of social media presence. For these reasons, the individually preferred choice of social media disconnection is experienced as justified, rational, and natural.

Are Universities Sites of Privilege, Sites of Resistance, or Vulnerable Institutions in a Digital Society?
In light of previous research, university leaders who refrain from using social media can be seen as privileged actors. Socially and structurally maintained conditions accommodated and enabled their disconnection from social media without undesirable consequences. The leaders we studied expressed confidence in their ability to succeed and advance in their work without the visibility, information, and influence afforded by social media. In a higher education environment that increasingly emphasizes competition, branding, and measurable visibility, opting out of social media also takes on a countercultural or dissenting, even resistant quality.

The findings highlight a paradox. Academic senior leaders possess resources that enable independent judgment and critical distance from dominant social expectations. Their silence on social media platforms can be understood as an important critical response to the power exercised by digital platforms. At the same time, research universities face pressure to meet the expectations of a society shaped by digital engagement, platform visibility, and mediated interaction. The same conditions that enable disconnection from social media may also make research universities vulnerable in a digital society. Absence from social media and the social processes associated with it may have implications for how publics perceive and justify research universities. Our findings prompt questions about the extent to which universities function as sites of privilege, sites of resistance, or vulnerable institutions in a digital society.

Our study, which used a social research methodology, highlights the distinctive nature of research universities as organizations and societal institutions. The findings suggest that the social media disconnection of academic senior leaders cannot be understood solely as an individual choice. Rather, it reflects broader relationships between academic leadership, academic identity, and institutional legacies, and the difficulty of adjusting them to the changing conditions of public life. Social media disconnection at the top of the university is not a curiosity but connected to pressing questions about the position of research universities in a digital society.

The data gathering stage of the study was funded by the Helsingin Sanomat Foundation.

Read the full article: When academic leaders disconnect from social media in Finland: Situational rationality, silent resistance.

---

Leena Ripatti-Torniainen, Docent and PhD, is a scholar in Media and Communication Studies, Higher Education, and the intersection of these two fields. She works as a University Lecturer and Team Leader in the Faculty of Education and Culture, Tampere University. She has explored the formation of the public through a range of theoretical and empirical approaches, highlighting less-known forms of publicness and public agency. Her research on universities has addressed the social and interactional processes that shape education, organizational development, decision-making, and leadership in research universities.

Her recent publications include:

Ripatti-Torniainen, L., Nevalainen, H. & Stevanovic, M. (2026). Sexism and silence in the university: Barriers to institutional accountability in the informal sites of student life. NORA – Nordic Journal of Feminist and Gender Research. https://doi.org/10.1080/08038740.2026.2747326

Ripatti-Torniainen, L. (2025). Toward the formation of the public in a marginalized communicative culture: Analyzing The Long Road of Woman’s Memory. Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy, 40(1), 107–124. https://doi.org/10.1017/hyp.2024.43

LinkedIn: Leena Ripatti-Torniainen.

---

Karoliina Talvitie-Lamberg, PhD, works as an Associate Professor of Communication and Media Research at the University of Jyväskylä. Her research focuses on questions of digital and social belonging and agency shaped by everyday media environments. Her current research centers on data-driven belonging, digital disconnection, and affective labour in journalism. She has acted as a PI in several research projects on affectivities in journalism, digital disconnection, ethical data practices, and AI for social wellbeing.

Her recent publications include:

Nikunen, K., Talvitie-Lamberg, K., & Valtonen, S. (2026). “All of us data points”: Experiences of data welfare state from the margins. The Information Society, 42(3), 167-180.

Talvitie-Lamberg, K., Lehtinen, V., & Valtonen, S. (2024). Tactics of invisibility: How people in vulnerable positions make datafied everyday life livable. New Media & Society, 26(9), 5445-5465.